VeabirdBeach

Jamaica vs the Bahamas

The Bahamas usually grades better in February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November and December, and the other months are close; Jamaica never beats it by a clear margin. In winter (December to February) the Bahamas is the stronger pick (B+ vs B). Seaweed: Jamaica peaks high in July, the Bahamas rarely sees any.

Month by month

A typical day in each month (median resort). Bold: better by a clear margin.

MonthJamaicaThe BahamasWaterRain chanceSeaweedCrowdsStorm risk
JanuaryB+B+82°F / 76°F34% / 34%Very low / RareVery busy / BusyVery low / Very low
FebruaryB+B+81°F / 75°F50% / 33%Low / RareVery busy / Very busyVery low / Very low
MarchB+A-82°F / 77°F61% / 36%Low / RareVery busy / Very busyVery low / Very low
AprilB-A-83°F / 77°F76% / 39%Low / RareBusy / Very busyVery low / Very low
MayB-A-84°F / 82°F70% / 52%Moderate / RareBusy / BusyVery low / Very low
JuneB-A-85°F / 85°F64% / 61%Moderate / RareBusy / BusyVery low / Very low
JulyB-A-85°F / 87°F61% / 57%High / RareBusy / Very busyLow / Low
AugustC+A-86°F / 87°F64% / 59%Moderate / RareBusy / BusyLow / Moderate
SeptemberC+A-87°F / 87°F70% / 63%Low / RareModerate / BusyLow / Moderate
OctoberC+B+87°F / 84°F75% / 56%Very low / RareModerate / BusyLow / Low
NovemberB-B+86°F / 80°F63% / 46%Very low / RareBusy / BusyLow / Low
DecemberBB+84°F / 77°F44% / 33%Very low / RareVery busy / Very busyVery low / Very low

Pairs of values read Jamaica / the Bahamas. From Veabird's year-ahead outlook (climate normals, holiday crowds and storm history) and Veabird's typical seaweed season (beach observations scaled by satellite data).

This week

Grades for the next few days at the resorts that usually do best this month.

Jamaica

The Bahamas

Grades for the next few days from Veabird's beach forecast, updated Nov 19, 01:00 UTC. Higher is better: A+ to F.

Jamaica forecast · The Bahamas forecast

Questions

Is Jamaica or the Bahamas better?
The Bahamas usually grades better in February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November and December, and the other months are close; Jamaica never beats it by a clear margin. In winter (December to February) the Bahamas is the stronger pick (B+ vs B). Seaweed: Jamaica peaks high in July, the Bahamas rarely sees any.
Which has warmer water, Jamaica or the Bahamas?
Jamaica averages 84°F over the year and the Bahamas 81°F. In January it is 82°F vs 76°F; in July 85°F vs 87°F.
Which is less crowded?
Jamaica is quietest in September and October; the Bahamas in September and October.
Which has less sargassum?
Over a typical year, seaweed averages low in Jamaica and very low in the Bahamas. Jamaica is lightest in January and October; the Bahamas in January and October.

More

Coordinates approximate; forecasts are estimates, not safety guidance.