Puerto Rico vs the US Virgin Islands
The US Virgin Islands usually grades better in April, September and October, and the other months are close; Puerto Rico never beats it by a clear margin. In winter (December to February) the two are close (both A-).
Month by month
A typical day in each month (median resort). Bold: better by a clear margin.
| Month | Puerto Rico | The US Virgin Islands | Water | Rain chance | Crowds | Storm risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| January | A- | A- | 82°F / 81°F | 46% / 37% | Very busy / Very busy | Very low / Very low |
| February | A- | B+ | 81°F / 80°F | 55% / 41% | Very busy / Very busy | Very low / Very low |
| March | B+ | A- | 81°F / 80°F | 53% / 32% | Very busy / Very busy | Very low / Very low |
| April | B+ | A- | 81°F / 81°F | 62% / 41% | Busy / Busy | Very low / Very low |
| May | A- | A- | 83°F / 83°F | 58% / 39% | Busy / Busy | Very low / Very low |
| June | A- | A- | 83°F / 84°F | 49% / 37% | Busy / Busy | Very low / Very low |
| July | B+ | B+ | 84°F / 84°F | 59% / 44% | Very busy / Busy | Low / Low |
| August | B+ | B+ | 85°F / 85°F | 62% / 50% | Busy / Busy | Moderate / Moderate |
| September | B+ | A- | 86°F / 86°F | 71% / 51% | Moderate / Moderate | Moderate / Moderate |
| October | B+ | A- | 86°F / 86°F | 67% / 56% | Busy / Moderate | Low / Moderate |
| November | B+ | B+ | 85°F / 85°F | 63% / 61% | Busy / Busy | Low / Low |
| December | B+ | A- | 83°F / 82°F | 53% / 41% | Very busy / Very busy | Very low / Very low |
Pairs of values read Puerto Rico / the US Virgin Islands. From Veabird's year-ahead outlook (climate normals, holiday crowds and storm history) and Veabird's typical seaweed season (beach observations scaled by satellite data).
This week
Grades for the next few days at the resorts that usually do best this month.
Puerto Rico
- Hotel Rumbao, A Tribute Portfolio HotelThuA-FriB+SatA-SunA-MonA-
- Villa Herencia HotelThuA-FriB+SatA-SunA-MonA-
- S.J. Suites HotelThuA-FriB+SatA-SunA-MonA-
- Condado Vanderbilt HotelThuA-FriB+SatA-SunA-MonA-
The US Virgin Islands
- Frederiksted Beach ResortsThuA-FriA-SatA-SunA-MonA-
- Sand Castle on the BeachThuA-FriA-SatA-SunA-MonA-
- The Hotel on the CayThuA-FriB+SatB+SunBMonB+
- Caneel Bay / North Shore St. John BeachesThuB+FriA-SatA-SunA-MonA-
Grades for the next few days from Veabird's beach forecast, updated Nov 19, 01:00 UTC. Higher is better: A+ to F.
Questions
- Is Puerto Rico or the US Virgin Islands better?
- The US Virgin Islands usually grades better in April, September and October, and the other months are close; Puerto Rico never beats it by a clear margin. In winter (December to February) the two are close (both A-).
- Which has warmer water, Puerto Rico or the US Virgin Islands?
- Puerto Rico averages 83°F over the year and the US Virgin Islands 83°F. In January it is 82°F vs 81°F; in July 84°F vs 84°F.
- Which is less crowded?
- Puerto Rico is quietest in September and October; the US Virgin Islands in September and October.